Home
Products
Caramel Apples
Latest Creations
Pick Your Own!
The Turtle Fleet
Caramels and Toffee
Clusters and Barks
Hand-Dipped Treats, et al
Peanut Butter Cups
Hallie's Fudge
Hand-Dipped Truffles
Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sourpatch, Seasonal Novelties
Quick & Dirty
Turtle Merch
About Turtle Alley
About Turtle Alley
Candyland in a Pandemic
Blog
Reviews
Contact Us
Shipping Policy
Home
Products
Caramel Apples
Latest Creations
Pick Your Own!
The Turtle Fleet
Caramels and Toffee
Clusters and Barks
Hand-Dipped Treats, et al
Peanut Butter Cups
Hallie's Fudge
Hand-Dipped Truffles
Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sourpatch, Seasonal Novelties
Quick & Dirty
Turtle Merch
About Turtle Alley
About Turtle Alley
Candyland in a Pandemic
Blog
Reviews
Contact Us
Shipping Policy
0
Cart
Recently Viewed
Home
Products
Caramel Apples
Latest Creations
Pick Your Own!
The Turtle Fleet
Caramels and Toffee
Clusters and Barks
Hand-Dipped Treats, et al
Peanut Butter Cups
Hallie's Fudge
Hand-Dipped Truffles
Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sourpatch, Seasonal Novelties
Quick & Dirty
Turtle Merch
About Turtle Alley
About Turtle Alley
Candyland in a Pandemic
Blog
Reviews
Contact Us
Shipping Policy
Collection
Peanut Butter Cups
Hallie’s handmade chocolate embraces hand-whisked, all-natural peanut butter for a bite-sized nugget of nirvana.
Filter
Sort
Filter
Apply
Sort
Apply
Spicy Peanut Butter Cup
From $16.00
White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
From $16.00
Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
From $16.00
Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
From $16.00
The King
From $16.00
You're viewing 5 of 5 products
Recently Viewed
