NOW OFFERING CURBSIDE PICKUP! SELECT "LOCAL PICKUP" AS YOUR DELIVERY OPTION DURING CHECK OUT.
Home
Products
Pick Your Own!
Fall Treats
The Turtle Fleet
Caramels and Toffee
Clusters and Barks
Hand-Dipped Treats, et al
Peanut Butter Cups
Hallie's Fudge
Hand-Dipped Truffles
Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sourpatch, Seasonal Novelties
Quick & Dirty
Caramel Apples
About Turtle Alley
About Turtle Alley
Candyland in a Pandemic
Blog
Reviews
Contact Us
Shipping Policy
Home
Products
Pick Your Own!
Fall Treats
The Turtle Fleet
Caramels and Toffee
Clusters and Barks
Hand-Dipped Treats, et al
Peanut Butter Cups
Hallie's Fudge
Hand-Dipped Truffles
Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sourpatch, Seasonal Novelties
Quick & Dirty
Caramel Apples
About Turtle Alley
About Turtle Alley
Candyland in a Pandemic
Blog
Reviews
Contact Us
Shipping Policy
0
Cart
Recently Viewed
Home
Products
Pick Your Own!
Fall Treats
The Turtle Fleet
Caramels and Toffee
Clusters and Barks
Hand-Dipped Treats, et al
Peanut Butter Cups
Hallie's Fudge
Hand-Dipped Truffles
Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sourpatch, Seasonal Novelties
Quick & Dirty
Caramel Apples
About Turtle Alley
About Turtle Alley
Candyland in a Pandemic
Blog
Reviews
Contact Us
Shipping Policy
Collection
Peanut Butter Cups
Hallie’s handmade chocolate embraces hand-whisked, all-natural peanut butter for a bite-sized nugget of nirvana.
Filter
Sort
Filter
Apply
Sort
Apply
Spicy Peanut Butter Cup
From $14.00
White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
From $14.00
Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
From $14.00
Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
From $14.00
The King
From $14.00
You're viewing 5 of 5 products
Recently Viewed
